Start with the first steep drop.
Scrub your retention graph from the beginning. Find the first point where the curve falls faster than it did in the preceding few seconds. Watch that exact moment without skipping ahead.
Write down what the viewer knows.
Does the viewer already know where the story is going? Can they see the result the title promised? In the Off Trail sample, the first steep drop comes at 0:18. The first summit shot appears at 0:34.
Move one piece of the payoff forward.
Try opening with two seconds of the summit before cutting back to the trailhead. Keep the rest of the introduction as close as possible so there is one clear change to review after the next upload.

